« Historic Fort Worth, worth preserving | Main | Sunday Morning in Venice »
What makes it a "better" painting? To fiddle or not to fiddle?

When I think I've completed a painting, I often ask "What might make this a better painting?" At least I might ask this if I have time, leisure and patience ahead of me. I know where this question will lead — tormented fiddling. And, so often fiddling isn't a good thing. I've had instructors say "Leave it alone!" "Stop!" But if something is naggingly not quite working, there's always a "what if" which calls to me later — when I think the painting might actually benefit from said fiddling. And ... sometime it does.
Above is a photo of some rhododendron blooms taken on Mt. Desert Island, Maine. Soft and delicate, I loved the "blushing" colors and the out-of-focus background with the "pops" of color peeking through.
Below is the initial painting. Which I was happy with — for a while. Yet something began to seem a little dull or gray. And, it didn't read well from across the room.

Wondering if it was the photo or the painting, I started by playing with things in Photoshop to see what might make an improved work. This is a fun thing to do without fatally moving beyond the "Stop!" point.
Photoshop has an autocolor and autotone setting. See below. Immediately with surprising results, it "pops" everything up and from here you can back it down to where you might want to leave it, thus letting one see how the painting could look. I can then decide if I can effectively translate the improvements to the panel with paint. Below you can see how these auto commands popped the colors and the background.

I sort of liked this but I think it's too harsh (especially the background). However, I could see I wanted more color in the work. Easy and harmless experimenting on the screen, so back to the easel where it is a little scarier to do this kind of experimenting. Yet, even without a paint "undo" command, I wanted to see something more exciting on the original panel. And it's really not too hard to keep reworking.
Here's the next try. Adding more color, softens the contrast in the background. Better — the colors are now more inviting, than the original, but still sort of dull. Maybe too little contrast?

So next I grayed and darkened the new colors in the background. Better still.

Now the only necessary improvements I can imagine are to add the tiniest bits of pale greens to the petals closest to the stems where they would have more of this color. It's a subtle difference, shown below, but I think this added more definition and volume to the buds' shapes.

"Blush," 6 x 8
Okay, so I also popped up the two leaves in the lower foreground to bring them forward.
Perfection is not attainable, better is.
C'est fini!
Art doesn't have to match a photographic image — in fact, it is better if it doesn't. Photos should really only be a starting point for artwork. (It's taken me years to give myself permission to say and do this!)
This, too, is going to the Art is the Preservation of the City show! It looks great in a gold frame!
Susan Fuquay
Connect:
Share:
Comments
* indicates a required field





